On Israel’s 73rd birthday, the tiny nation is all over the news as vicious violence erupts–again. And–again–much of what we’re reading in major media is founded in lies. Going back to the roots of the decades-old conflict, there are some key facts many may not be aware of. And numerous distortions that are getting passed off as truth.
Starting with this week’s armed conflict, here’s some on-the-ground reality:
“This has nothing to do with Sheikh Jarrah: It’s about Hamas seeing a chance to seize the narrative and increase its own influence and control over Palestinians in Jerusalem,” by Bassem Eid, Times of Israel, May 12, 2021:
…As a Palestinian living in Jerusalem, I am frustrated and angry — and I can only blame Hamas. The fanatics who rule over Gaza with an iron first cannot resist the opportunity to stir up anti-Jewish violence for their own political gain. If innocent Jews and Muslims die in the process, all the better for them.The pretext for the latest missile barrage and social media incitement is Sheikh Jarrah, where a long-running legal dispute was scheduled for a court hearing. This had been a private matter between Jews who have an old property deed from the 1800s and the residents of four homes who have lived there for decades and do not want to pay rent. It is the kind of situation that should be handled by a local municipal court. This could happen in any other country and there would be no public interest. But this is Jerusalem, so you have to view everything in the context of the political situation. You also have to ask yourself: who stands to gain from political violence right now?
…Hamas simply saw an opportunity it could not pass up, exploiting the Sheikh Jarrah situation and an already tense environment during the holy day of Leylat Al Qadr and Jerusalem Day. Hamas is currently running a social media campaign calling for Palestinians to incite violence during demonstrations in Jerusalem and elsewhere. They are encouraging Palestinian youth to throw their lives away by hurling rocks and makeshift bombs at police.
Hamas-led riots outside of the Al Aqsa Mosque prove that Israeli police are not at fault for the dangers preventing Muslims from praying. Hamas has incited mobs and provoked violence with the intention of framing Israel for ethnic cleansing. Just today, provocateurs filled several busses to travel to Jerusalem to participate in the “historic” riots and answer the Hamas call to incite violence….
This dispute is not actually about four houses in East Jerusalem. This is about Hamas seeing a chance to seize the narrative and increase its own influence and control over Palestinians in Jerusalem. Don’t buy their fake news and let them dilute their own blame. In the coming days, Jews and Muslims are both likely to die because Hamas saw political upside in violence. Don’t forget it.
Disproportionate, much? But this is how Hamas demonstrates that it is the “defender of Jerusalem.”
Although it’s easy and convenient for the progressive media to blame Israel, there are many factors behind the horrible no-win situation of the inhabitants of Gaza and the West Bank.
For a fiery first-hand perspective from a Palestinian on who’s responsible for depriving the Palestinian Arabs of their future, please see this video:
Here are a few more points that seem to get overlooked in the coverage.
The PA has received billions of dollars in international aid and yet has failed to build a single house to allow even one family to move out of a refugee camp into permanent housing. Given the amount of aid (approximately $5.5 billion since 1993) the PA has received, it is shocking and outrageous that more than half a million Palestinians are being forced by their own leaders to remain in squalid camps. – Jewish Virtual Library
During the years that Israel controlled the Gaza Strip, a consistent effort was made to get the Palestinians into permanent housing. The Palestinians opposed the idea because the frustrated and bitter inhabitants of the camps provided the various terrorist factions with their manpower. Moreover, the Arab states routinely pushed for the adoption of UN resolutions demanding that Israel desist from the removal of Palestinian refugees from camps in Gaza and the West Bank. They preferred to keep the Palestinians as symbols of Israeli “oppression.” – Jewish Virtual Library
The situation in the Palestine refugee camps is indeed wrenching. But Israel is not to blame.
How does the world wind up getting fed such a strident one-sided view by the mainstream press? This article from the venerable Atlantic is a long but thoughtful confessional by a veteran AP reporter. It details how and why the press corps colludes with Hamas.
The AP staff in Gaza City would witness a rocket launch right beside their office, endangering reporters and other civilians nearby—and the AP wouldn’t report it. (This happened.) Hamas fighters would burst into the AP’s Gaza bureau and threaten the staff—and the AP wouldn’t report it. (This also happened.) Cameramen waiting outside Shifa Hospital in Gaza City would film the arrival of civilian casualties and then, at a signal from an official, turn off their cameras when wounded and dead fighters came in, helping Hamas maintain the illusion that only civilians were dying. (This too happened; the information comes from multiple sources with firsthand knowledge of these incidents.)… To offer another illustration, the construction of 100 apartments in a Jewish settlement is always news; the smuggling of 100 rockets into Gaza by Hamas is, with rare exceptions, not news at all.
This is a slightly tangential point, but is Israel an “apartheid state” as some claim? On the contrary, Israel is the only nation in the region which extends equal rights to its minority citizens! (Try being a non-Muslim, or a Muslim woman for that matter, in Saudi Arabia or Iran.) Check out this video from Prager U for a Black South African’s perspective on this question.
Many attempts have been made to define a plan to divide the holy land between Arabs and Jews. Let’s take a minute to trace the history.
How British Palestine Came to Be
In 1922, after the Ottoman Empire fell at the end of WWI, the League of Nations granted the British a Mandate to govern an area the British (not the Arab residents, who had been citizens of the Ottomans) named “Palestine.” The Mandate’s express purpose? To establish “a national home for the Jewish people.”
During the first decades of the twentieth century, Jewish people were allowed to immigrate freely into British Palestine. Some came, purchasing land legally from Arab families who were happy to sell it. But they didn’t come in great numbers. Why? Because life in Palestine was hard! The land they were able to purchase was generally undesirable. They persisted through years of toil to reclaim malarial swamps or to coax crops from arid sand. You had to be young, hardy, and a bit of a zealot for the pioneering Zionist life to appeal.
Worse, as the Jewish population increased, it became the target of random violence by Arab neighbors. Episodes got more frequent, climaxing in the Arab Revolt of 1936-1939. More than three hundred Jews were murdered during the Revolt years alone.
In 1937, the British formed a body called the Peel Commission to make a recommendation. Its recommendation looked like this:
According to this proposal, the Jewish State would get the smaller area within the red lines. Jerusalem would be in an international zone governed by the British. The Jews agreed to this partition plan. But the Arabs rejected it, continuing the murderous Arab Revolt I mentioned above.
It took the sweeping horror of the Holocaust to move world sympathy enough to persuade the new United Nations to ratify a new plan. The land the United Nations voted to grant to Israel in May, 1948, looked like this:
The crazy-shaped blue area was Israel. Jerusalem (in gray) was, again, to be a special international zone.
The Jewish State looks like indefensible Swiss cheese here! The big pointed piece at the bottom is the Negev desert–forbidding land not suitable for either agriculture or urban development at that time. Nonetheless, the Jewish negotiators agreed to this plan. The Arab negotiators did not.
Please note that non-Jewish residents of Palestine were not asked to give up their homes or their civil rights, which were guaranteed. They were not asked to give up their self-determination–they never had it to begin with. Palestinian Arabs were not a distinct political or ethnic entity. They’d been ruled for centuries by the Ottomans out of Damascus (not Jerusalem), and then by the British.
But those who wished to remain in the Jewish sections would need to accept Jewish leadership. That the Arab world would not submit to. Instead, Palestine plunged into a state of undeclared civil war. This began months before the partition officially took effect on May 15, 1948.
Violence escalated. The day Israel became a nation, seven surrounding states attacked it. Heavily armored columns bore down on Jewish farming communities whose defense consisted of molotov cocktails and a motley assortment of smuggled rifles–smuggled, because they had been illegal for them to own under the British mandate. Perhaps with the addition of a light mortar or two and what little ammunition the nascent Israeli Defense Force could supply.
Many Arabs fled Israel voluntarily at this time, understandably fearful to remain in a war zone. Some were, frankly, expelled at gunpoint. Once it became clear the Arabs would not support the Jewish state, the fledgling nation couldn’t afford to leave villages in place in strategic locations where they could easily harbor and support its enemies.
Were there wartime atrocities? Sadly, yes. Both ways.
But the narrative that makes the Jewish State out to be the bully in the neighborhood, picking fights with unarmed Arab villagers, turns the facts upside down.
Israel made the Palestinians fresh offers in 2000 and 2008. Both would have given the Palestinians their own state including all of Gaza and the majority of the West Bank, with East Jerusalem as their capital. Yasser Arafat turned down the first deal (which Bill Clinton helped broker) and Mahmoud Abbas the second.
Former Israeli Prime Minister Golda Meir (1898-1978) is quoted as saying, “We will perhaps in time be able to forgive the Arabs for killing our sons, but it will be harder to forgive them for having forced us to kill theirs.”
Many Holocaust victims were still behind barbed wire five years after WWII!
If you listen to the popular press, you’re encouraged to form a picture in which a ruthless and well-armed Jewish war machine evicted unarmed Arab peasants from their villages. In fact, the nation of Israel came into being as an act of compassion toward one of the most brutally persecuted minorities ever—European Jewry, still reeling from the savage genocide suffered under Hitler.
Seventy-six years ago, the world was shocked and horrified as the extent of the Holocaust extermination machine was unveiled. Six million Jews, half of Europe’s Jewish population and a third of the world’s, slaughtered in less than five brutal years. Along with five million others—priests and pastors, gypsies, Jehovah’s Witnesses, communists, anarchists, Poles and other Slavic peoples, not to mention resistance fighters.
When the Allied armies liberated the concentration camps in 1945, I always believed that the captives were quickly nursed back to health and freed. But in researching a future novel, I’ve learned that picture is heartbreakingly inaccurate. The war left 250,000 Jewish displaced persons interned around Europe—many of them still confined in overcrowded conditions on the grounds of the camps in which they’d endured so much.
Holocaust survivors liberated from the Mauthausen camp in Austria.
Many Holocaust victims were still living behind barbed wire in those camps five years later. They didn’t want to—or couldn’t—return to their former homes where they’d faced so much persecution. How and where to resettle them became a humanitarian crisis of global proportion. The majority of them stated they had a single dream: to “make aliyah” or immigrate to their own land, in what was then Mandatory British Palestine.
Wedding dress sewn from parachute silk. It was reused by a succession of Jewish brides in the Celle and Belsen camps–former concentration camps made over to house Jewish “displaced persons.” The dress is displayed at the U.S. Holocaust History Museum.
What’s the bottom line here?
“My counsel shall stand, and I will do all My pleasure.” (Is 46:10)
Modern Israel is a dramatic fulfillment of dozens of Bible prophecies—see Dr. Ken Johnson’s list here. Tragically for the Palestinians, by choosing to embrace Hamas—which is actually the Hebrew word for violence (חָמָ֗ס, hamas)—rather than to seek peace, they have become the flashpoint around which prophecy is being fulfilled:
“Why do the nations rage,
And the people plot a vain thing?
The kings of the earth set themselves,
And the rulers take counsel together,
Against the Lord and against His Anointed, saying,
“Let us break Their bonds in pieces
And cast away Their cords from us.”
He who sits in the heavens shall laugh;
The Lord shall hold them in derision.
Then He shall speak to them in His wrath,
And distress them in His deep displeasure:
“Yet I have set My King
On My holy hill of Zion.” (Ps 2:1-6)
Apparently the Lord has no issue with recognizing Jerusalem… as the seat of His soon-coming King! For more on Israel’s place in end-time prophecy, please see this post.
The refugees in Gaza may repeat a narrative about “right of return” to their villages, but make no mistake: at the end of the day the raging on Israel’s borders is about Jerusalem and her glorious prophetic destiny. “As in the days of Noah” (Luke 17:26, Gen 6:11), the earth today is filled with violence–חָמָ֗ס– and again the word used in these Hebrew passages is Hamas!
As the last-days prophetic picture continues to fall into place, I am confident we haven’t heard the final word from Hamas, or from the nations raging against God and against His ultimate redemptive plan for “the holy hill of Zion.” (Ps 2:6)
If you’ve never opened God’s free gift of salvation through Jesus (Rom 3:23, 6:23), please please please be persuaded to do it now! It’s simple. Just tell God from your heart that you admit you’re a sinner that needs a Savior (“For all have sinned and fall short of the glory of God.” Rom 3:23) that you’re done running your own life, and that you’re ready to make Jesus Lord of your life.
If you confess with your mouth Jesus as Lord, and believe in your heart that God has raised Him from the dead, you shall be saved. For with the heart a person believes, resulting in righteousness, and with the mouth he confesses, resulting in salvation. For the Scripture says, “Whoever believes in Him will not be disappointed.” (Rom 10:9-11)
The decision that saves you is that simple!
Simple… But no one said living it out will be easy. Especially now.
Click on the image for an informal trailer, or….
Dave made aviation history in WWII’s daring Doolittle Raid. Now he’s a downed pilot on the run.
Miyako made a vow to bury a knife in him. That vow could cost them both their lives.
Winner, Cascade Award
Finalist, Christy and Carol Awards
Inspired by Actual Events
“A taut, crisp debut achievement that colorfully evokes the Pacific theater of WWII. Start this one forewarned: it’s a stay-up-all-night read.” –Jerry B. Jenkins, 21-time New York Times bestselling author
China, 1942. Desperate and fleeing a brutal enemy, U.S. airman Dave Delham loses all hope he’ll live to see home again. If he manages to survive this mission–somehow–he swears he’ll answer God’s call on his life.
Japan, 1948. In a world where honor means everything, what would you risk to salvage yours? The war has reduced Miyako Matsuura to a street-hardened prostitute, forced to sell herself out–body and soul–to survive. But when the pilot whose bomb stole her little brother’s life returns to Japan, she sees her one chance to salvage everything. That quest drives her like the point of a dagger.
Two competing vows. Two war-damaged people racing along a deadly collision course. Can their tragic histories be redeemed?
If you like pulse-pounding tales of redemption that brim with deeply drawn characters and taut suspense, you’ll love Linda Thompson’s powerful debut novel. Immerse yourself in this award-winning story of courage and redemption today!